Posted by michael david on July 01, 1999 at 18:10:56:
In Reply to: Shahsavan Mafrash Panel posted by Steve Price on July 01, 1999 at 09:31:26:
: Dear Folks,
: Here's part of a Shahsavan cargo bag panel that I think is quite old (whatever that means).
: The colors all look natural, and the green is obviously done by the two-dye method in which the wool is dyed with indigo and with some yellow dye (which you can see poking through where the indigo has abraded away in spots).
: Among the reasons for thinking that this is a very old piece is the morphology of some of the motifs. The border just above the white-ground birds-on-a-pole stripe consists of what looks like an early form of what is seen in later pieces as a nice, neat rhombus with nice, neat hooks projecting from both ends. The one just below the white ground stripe also has an archaic look compared to the same motifs in many Shahsavan mafrash.
: We might suppose that the person who did this just wasn't very good at drawing, but the drawing in the white ground stripe and in the widest stripe are very well done.
: Okay, you can start picking on me again now.
: Steve Price
I certainly don't want to pick on anyone but I own a rug which has a good green not dissimilar from your description. Other colors and "experts" believe it to be from the 1930-1950 period. I remember reading a Joan Allgrove monograph a few years back in which she stated and illustrated a Qashgai rug which she said most people would date to 1900. In fact she had first hand knowledge that it was woven in the 1940's. I always appreciate your viewpoint and your interpretation
so keep up the good work.